Maintaining the raised beds
2 04 2008
I’ve been readying the vegetable beds so the Other Half and I can start planting out brassicas, onions and broad beans between now and Sunday, but ran into a few problems with this bed and another. They’re the first two we built four years ago and are showing signs of their age.

The pressure-treated planks weren’t too bad—especially considering they were salvaged from old fences—but the pressure from my digging was the last straw for the screws and nails, which failed leaving the planks to come adrift from the stakes.

There was no point in leaving the beds as they were, so I took a break from digging and brought out a few more tools: side axe (for prying timbers apart and sharpening stakes, claw hammer for removing old nails, power drill, bits and a bag of decking screws. I also used a handsaw. The piece of slate is my garden workbench. It keeps tools, particularly power tools, off the damp ground.

The reclaimed decking screws I used four years ago were not in good shape, but at least they unscrewed easily.

The nails were in even worse shape, especially as they were supposedly galvanised. All I can say is that the galvanising must have been very, very thin indeed. (And they weren’t salvaged either.)

The temptation is to use the power drill to drive the screws in directly, but it should be resisted—especially with old, dry timber that splits easily. Drill a pilot hole first. The hole is angled to help prevent the plank popping off the stakes (put one screw or nail in at a downward angle, then the other at an upward angle). It’s preferable to use a wood bit, not an HSS bit as I’m using, but I broke my last one when it hit a piece of metal embedded in a stake (and that’s why I always wear safety glasses).

Countersink the hole next. Again, this helps stop the wood from splitting.

Finally, drive the screw home using an appropriate torque setting. Don’t over-drive the screw or the wood will split. If you’re not sure what setting to use, start with a lower amount of torque and work up until the screw goes in smoothly. I don’t use clamps for rough work like this, simply holding the wood in place with a knee or a hand (but well out of way of the drill).

If, despite your best efforts, the wood still wants to split hold it together with a screw driven vertically down the plank. It only works with thick planking, but if it works you can get another few years out of the plank.

With the corners restored, I turned my attention to the long sides. I used untreated wood to make the retaining pegs but these had rotted away, allowing the weight of the soil to push the top planks out of line. (The top of the lower plank can be just seen to the right of the base of the top plank.)

I have a pile of broken hardwood garden stakes that’s kept especially for jobs like this. I picked out a handful of broken lengths, sawed the tops square, cut them to length and sharpened them with the side axe to create new pegs. They will rot, but I’ll get another three to four years use from the timber which is much better than throwing them on a fire.

I used an old lump hammer to drive the new pegs in along the length of the beds. It’s not a good idea to use the back of the side axe or the claw hammer. It takes a lot more force to drive the pegs with the lighter axe or claw hammer than it does with the heavier hammer. As a result, it’s much easier for the axe to bounce back on impact, leaving you with the blade stuck in your head.

With the sides restored, the soil turned over and raked, and the weeds and stones removed, the bed is ready to take the brassica transplants and seedlings. It only leaves me with another three brassica beds to do. And four legume beds. And four leaf vegetable beds. And four root vegetable beds. Actually, it’s not quite that bad as some were dug in February, some were limed and dug last autumn and some don’t have wooden sides yet. Still, it’s busy days for us.


What a co-incidence Stoney. I am doing much the same work at present as we head into the cold weather, while your weather is warming. The main difference is my garden beds have old railway sleepers around them so I do not have the worry of splitting timbers. I simply turn them upside down to help continue their long life.
The nails were propably electro-galvanised which is very thin or cadmium plated. Hot-dipped galvanised is best as the process gives a thicker zinc coating.
Unfortunately, the galvanising method is not usually specified on the label. I do have a collection of reclaimed brass screws I use for important outdoor jobs, but the raised beds aren’t one of them.
Howdy,
I can relate personally to your raised beds and planting, but being mechanically challenged, I use the beautiful concept of division-of-labor for my carpentry projects. Scott, my great housemate who trades work for rent, handles them. Everyone benefits . . . . .all a part of my evolving concept of the Diamond Cut Life. Please come visit at http://alison97215.wordpress.com.
Best,
Alison in Portland, Oregon
Doh… I wish I had read this before I built my 4 frames for my beds (which I did today)… I think they will need some more work
I have another 12 to dig from scratch, and build frames for and plant up. At least I have a better idea of what to do now.
Is there anything that is suitable to treat the wood with? I know you shouldn’t treat them with cuprinol or anything toxic but I was thinking veg oil or something, just to prolong the life of the wood… or is that just crazy talk?
Annpan, there certainly are non-toxic equivalents - we used to use them each year to treat the external surfaces of our (British National) beehives when we kept bees (Western Red Cedar is very very good but, without treatment, won’t keep forever!) unfortunately I cannot recall the brandname, but you could do worse than checking out suppliers of beekeepers accessories…
If you can afford it, the best way to avoid wood preservatives is to use well-seasoned European oak or sweet chestnut, both of which are very durable although you need corrosion resistant fixings (stainless steel or brass). Western red cedar is durable but less so than these two, while larch is a step down from cedar. (But preservatives will make all of these last longer).
If you are using pressure-treated timber and are worried about toxicity, look for timber treated with tanalith E—that’s the European approved, child-safe preservative. If it’s okay for climbing frames and swings, it should be okay for gardens.
After that, you’re looking at boron-based compounds, which are water soluble and non-toxic. I think they need to be used on green timbers, though, or at least ones that have a high moisture content.
I use Cuprinol Clear Wood Preserver on bee hives as it’s insecticide free. I’m not worried about it being unsafe, but I know there are people who treat all preservatives with suspicion.
I wouldn’t used old treated sleepers in the UK as most have been treated with very toxic compounds, quite a few of which are now illegal. Untreated hardwood sleepers would be good if you can get them.
Personally, I’d have preferred not to use wood at all and would have opted for reclaimed bricks or concrete blocks as these act as a heat sink (useful in our cool climate) and last for years. But it’s not easy to find enough blocks or bricks for an area as large as ours. I know where there’s a large fire-damaged pile of several thousand but the owners wanted 50 pence a block!
We do have some raised beds without any hard borders and these work well, but the maintenance requirements are different. Wood (and other hard borders) harbour weeds around the edges, while the edges of wood-lined beds can dry out faster (not a problem with blocks). Raised earth beds without borders don’t harbour weeds, but tend to collapse outwards under their own weight and are eroded by birds.